China-trained vs. US-trained acupuncturists: the undeniable gap in education, experience, and funding

When I moved to San Francisco, I interviewed at one of the Bay Area’s highly rated acupuncture clinics. I left disappointed by the clinical skills I saw and the reluctance to collaborate. It made me wonder how patients could judge a practitioner’s experience beyond reviews.

I studied Chinese medicine in Beijing and California. Over 17 years in practice, I have run clinics in both places, supervised students at AIMC, an acupuncture school in the Bay Area, and treated patients from over 60 countries. I have seen how differently the two systems prepare us for the patients who walk through our doors.

The gap between China and the US is a sensitive subject. I want to explain what differs in training, techniques and clinical experience, and what those differences mean for patients choosing care.

In the US, acupuncture gets narrowed to pain

Most American adults who used acupuncture in the 2022 National Health Interview Survey used it for pain. In our comparison of US acupuncture searches over the past year, pain led every other condition by a wide margin.

In the US, Chinese medicine is reduced to acupuncture, and acupuncture to pain relief

Google Trends · share of selected search interest (%) · US

Pain
66.4%
Anxiety
9.1%
Neuropathy
5.5%
Depression
4.5%
Migraine
3.6%
Insomnia
2.7%
Stroke
2.7%
Other
5.5%

73% of US adult acupuncture users used it for pain.
National Health Interview Survey, 2022

Google Trends: October 2025–September 2026, common-anchor comparison.
Percentages normalize the selected terms’ index scores to 100%; not all acupuncture searches.
National patient survey: NCCIH / NHIS 2022.
Other: tinnitus, infertility, constipation, allergy, menopause, and digestion.

Chinese medicine in China's primary care covers far more. In Shenzhen community health centres in the first half of 2021, respiratory conditions were the largest group, followed by muscle and joint problems, gynaecological, cardiovascular and digestive problems.

In China, Chinese medicine
is ordinary primary care.

Respiratory
54.19%
Muscle and joint
19.05%
Gynecological
7.95%
Cardiovascular / cerebrovascular
7.15%
Digestive
4.98%
Other categories
6.68%
Share of 385,138 TCM records · Shenzhen · Jan–Jun 2021
Source: Chinese General Practice, 26(25), 2023.
Family-doctor-contracted residents; study-defined TCM diagnosis groups.

Coverage keeps it narrow here. Medicare pays for acupuncture for one condition only, chronic low back pain, and where US hospitals offer it, it is mostly for pain and the side effects of cancer treatment. A complicated case is rarely only pain.

An acupuncture clinic in the US Roughly what gets paid for, and so roughly what walks in
  • Pain
  • Sometimes fertility
  • Beauty & skin care
A Chinese medicine hospital in China Departments, the way any hospital has departments
  • Paediatrics
  • Digestion
  • Dermatology
  • Gynaecology
  • Neurology
  • Oncology

People take a child with a cough to one of those, or a rash, or a stomach that has never been right.

Acupuncture is far wider than the needles most people picture, and still growing

The acupuncture most people picture, fine needles left in the back or legs, is one method among many. China's national standard for acupuncture and moxibustion techniques has 22 parts, each setting out how one technique is done, from scalp and ear needling to fire needles, thread embedding and cupping, and its newest part was published in 2026.

At the Second Affiliated Hospital of Zhejiang Chinese Medical University, the acupuncture department lists 23 therapies.

Several of these are recent. Scalp acupuncture took shape in the 1970s and Fu's subcutaneous needling in 1996. Some have crossed the Pacific: in 2024, about 70% of American practitioners used electroacupuncture.

Acupuncture needles inserted along zones of a patient's scalp above the ear
Scalp acupunctureNeedles placed along mapped zones of the scalp. Several schools exist; Jiao Shunfa began his in 1971, and the photo shows Zhu's.Liao et al., Frontiers in Medicine
Four fine acupuncture needles inserted in the outer ear
Ear acupuncturePoints on the outer ear stand in for the rest of the body. Paul Nogier published the modern ear map in France in 1957, and China has a national standard for ear points.L. Beck, Wikimedia Commons
Small balls of moxa burning on the handles of acupuncture needles in a patient's back, with smoke rising
Warm needleA small ball of moxa, dried mugwort, burns on the needle handle so the warmth travels down the needle.Wonderlane, Flickr
A practitioner heats a fire needle red-hot over an alcohol flame held in forceps
Fire needleA needle heated red-hot in a flame and inserted for a moment.Ai et al., Medicine
Dr Deb guides a patient's arm through a movement while a Fu's subcutaneous needle lies flat under the skin of the upper arm
Fu's subcutaneous needlingThe needle lies flat under the skin, above the muscle, while the patient moves the tight area against my hand.
Dr Deb placing a cheek acupuncture needle on a patient lying on a treatment couch
Cheek acupunctureShallow needles at a standard map of points on the cheek, used to treat pain elsewhere in the body. Created by Wang Yongzhou and his team.

In San Francisco I use cheek acupuncture and Fu's needling on top of classical acupuncture, and I hold certificates in both.

My training was longer and more clinical than a US acupuncture degree

In China, Chinese medicine is taught as medicine. At Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, where I did my bachelor's degree and my PhD, the acupuncture pathway runs five undergraduate years plus three postgraduate years that include standardised hospital residency. Students learn Chinese medicine alongside anatomy, physiology, pathology, pharmacology, internal medicine, surgery and emergency medicine.

The US certification board's standard is a three-year master's in acupuncture, or four years with herbal medicine, which students typically start after two years of college. California asks for 3,000 hours, 950 of them supervised clinical work, plus a licensing exam. No hospital residency is required.

I have sat in both classrooms. Between my Chinese bachelor's degree and my PhD, I earned a master's at South Baylo University in California, and its coursework was easier than my Chinese undergraduate courses.

8 years of medical training.
A 3-year acupuncture degree.

Different training, different clinical infrastructure.

ChinaUnited States

Licensed practitioners

TCM physicians, China 2024; acupuncture licenses, US 2023

China
971,000
United States
34,000

Dedicated Chinese medicine hospitals

China’s national hospital network; US practice is mainly independent clinics

China
6,397
United StatesNo comparable network

Years in specialist training pathways

BUCM degree + residency; US acupuncture master’s programme

China
8 years
United States
3 years
Adapted from the original Dr Deb comparison.
Sources: China NHC 2024; Fan et al. 2023 license count; BUCM; NCBAHM.

Chinese hospitals send their acupuncturists more patients and harder cases

Dr Deb with colleagues in maroon scrubs, smiling for a selfie at Beijing United Family Hospital
At Beijing United Family Hospital, working across Chinese and Western medicine was routine. I often collaborated with colleagues in neurology, orthopaedics, obstetrics and paediatrics.

At Beijing United Family Hospital I was the Chinese medicine department, seeing 45 to 60 patients a week, about a fifth of them children. Colleagues from other departments sent me their difficult cases: chronic conditions, new symptoms nobody could place, a facial paralysis that had lasted ten years. I sent patients the other way just as easily. We talked about shared patients all the time, so a referral felt like asking a colleague down the hall for help.

Volume is where the experience gap opens. Acupuncturists at a Jiangsu teaching hospital in 2018 saw about four times as many patients per week as practitioners in a 2014 to 2016 US survey.

Clinical exposure grows
with patient contact.

Weekly workload per practitioner · published examples

China · teaching-hospital benchmarkUS · practitioner survey
China · Jiangsu hospital
97 / week
US · NCCAOM survey
24 / week
China: 2018 hospital visits / 33 doctors / 250 workdays, × 5 days.
US: mean patients/week, 1,047 NCCAOM respondents, 2014–2016.
Sources: Fan et al., Medical Acupuncture 2020; Ward-Cook et al., 2017.

In the US the same medicine mostly works alone. In 2024, 70% of US acupuncturists ran their own practice and about 5% worked in a hospital outpatient clinic. Seeing that many patients, with specialists referring difficult cases and discussing them with you, gives you clinical experience that is hard to get in a solo practice.

>80% are complicated cases

I treat complicated cases in San Francisco

80% of my patients have four or more symptoms when they first come to see me. Over 50% have symptoms spread across five or more body systems.

“I love San Francisco, but it can be intense.”

The body is one integrated system. A headache is rarely only a headache. It is often the first signal of a load the whole system is carrying: cervical tension, eye strain, short sleep, sustained stress, a routine the body has stopped tolerating quietly. Every case starts with a full examination, tongue, pulse, palpation and history, before any needle. Then I treat the pattern behind the symptoms, not the one spot that hurts.

Why patients comeShare of cases by the main reason for the visit.
What they also carryShare of patients reporting each factor at intake. One patient can count in several rows.
How many systems are involvedShare of patients with at least one symptom in each body system.
  • Musculoskeletal73%
  • Digestive60%
  • Neuropsychological53%
  • Skin53%
  • Cardiovascular47%
  • Respiratory40%
Dr. Deborah Ma, PhDAcupuncturist · Trained in Beijing, China · 17 years of experience前北京和睦家医院中医科主治中医 Rated 4.9/5 and trusted by 3,600+ patients.

Talk to Dr. Deb before you decide.

“She's the first doctor that made me feel human and not like just another nameless number.”

GC, on Zocdoc
What’s included
  • Discuss your health concerns and goals
  • Address any questions before committing to your first appointment
  • We'll determine the best approach

Loading available times…

See other times

Pick a time

Dr. Deborah Ma

15-minute Free consultation

What would you like help with?

Complicated cases are not rare. On a cruise ship they were almost all I saw.

Illustration of Dr Deb in a white coat waving from a cruise ship at sea

From 2012 to 2014 I worked as a Chinese medicine doctor on Norwegian Cruise Line ships in the Mediterranean, treating 70 to 80 patients a week. They came from many countries and very different lives. Many were older and living with several conditions at once, and for most it was their first acupuncture. What brought them in was a problem they had carried for years without an answer, and the time at sea to try something new.

Robert H., a passenger, wrote afterwards:

"I have this rare nerve disease where temperature changes trigger intense pain, for 30 years. Honestly, I wasn't expecting much from the spa acupuncturist on a cruise ship. [...] Somehow she managed to treat this condition that had stumped doctors for decades, just with acupuncture."

He expected a spa treatment, and I do not blame him. Nothing about a cruise spa, or a US acupuncture licence, tells a patient that the person holding the needles trained as a hospital doctor.

What I admire about US-trained acupuncturists

Some of the US-trained acupuncturists I know are wonderful at making people feel cared for from the moment they walk in. Music, comfortable reclining chairs, warm lighting and thoughtfully designed rooms can make a visit feel like a spa experience. I appreciate the attention to helping people relax, especially in the Bay Area, where so many of us live at an intense pace.

Two views of an acupuncture setting with reclining chairs, warm lighting and overhead screens showing nature scenes
Comfortable chairs, warm lighting and calming surroundings make the patient experience part of the care.

I also admire practitioners who make mental health and cultural belonging central to their work. Tina Pham at Persimmon Acupuncture, who trained in San Francisco, is one example. She speaks openly about emotional well-being and intergenerational healing, and makes room for Asian American culture through art, food and community gatherings. Persimmon has even hosted a phở fundraiser with the SF Asian Women’s Shelter. I love seeing a clinic become a place where people can feel at home in their culture and talk about what they are carrying emotionally. This attention to mental health and community is something I would like to see developed further in Chinese medicine in China, too.

Jackie Liu’s painting Brunch of Good Fortune: a woman beside a table of food
Brunch of Good Fortune by Jackie Liu, shared by Persimmon Acupuncture.

There is also room here for practitioners to develop their own style. In conversations with doctors, physical therapists and massage therapists, I have met people who have also trained in acupuncture. It becomes another tool they can draw on alongside their other skills, whether that is integrative medicine, rehabilitation or hands-on bodywork. I love the diversity of this community and the willingness to learn across disciplines. Patients benefit when we understand more than one way of approaching their care.

We all need to keep learning

A China-trained practitioner is not automatically better than a US-trained one. Training and clinical resources matter, but so does our willingness to keep learning.

As I write this, I am in China taking the final level of cheek acupuncture training, a course I had been on a waiting list to attend. Even after 17 years in practice, I still need to step outside my own clinic and become a student again.

Dr Deb attending cheek acupuncture training in China
Back in China for the final level of cheek acupuncture training.

I hope patients will give China-trained practitioners a chance. Many of us were taught to be modest and let our work speak for itself. After years of medical education, explaining that experience in a new language and culture is another challenge. I know that adjustment personally.

I am grateful to the patients in the Bay Area who trust me with their complicated cases. They keep me learning. I started Puzzle Exchange to give practitioners a place to share what works and learn from one another.

Free consultation Google reviews